Blog

Read our news and take a look at Q&A with Dr. Chynn.

SMILE

Q:

I will put my $0.02 here for what it’s worth.

In theory the structural integrity from SMILE should be better but independent in vivo research is needed. Dan Reinstein is a consultant for Zeiss.

SMILE has a lot of attractive features but sadly my evaluation from peers who used it and abandoned it is that outcomes are less predictable and take much longer to stabilise. The visumax laser is also not a good flap maker. It has been available outside the US for some years now but is not gaining traction.

Certainly the CEO of a large European refractive surgery company does not believe it has realistic potential. They tried hard to integrate it into their practice but failed and returned the machine.

I’d be interested to hear from those who have had a positive experience with the Visumax versus Alcon FS or Abbott iFS.

Suheb 

Melbourne

Australia

Answer by Emil Chynn:

I’ve done SMILE a few times in Europe

What’s the real benefit of a procedure that’s

Incisional

Doesn’t correct astigmatism

Doesn’t correct hyperopia

Can’t correct CK?

That makes it’s effective parameters low myopia.

There are MDs in Europe performing smile and then a LASEK or PRK on top to get rid of cyl or HOA. Sounds nuts to me

From my POV it’s greatest asset is a good marketing name?

Or am I missing something here?

Emil William Chynn, MD, FACS, MBA

Harvard/Columbia/Dartmouth/NYU/Emory-trained

1st eye surgeon in NY to get LASIK himself (1999)

Performed 5,000 LASIKs from 1996-2002

Switched to non-invasive LASEK in 2003

Have performed more LASEKs than any MD in US

 

Write a Comment

Research Methods Rigor

Minas, Clive, et al First of all, I’d like to congratulate Minas on finding an article I had published in Arch Ophth over …

Nursing and LASIK

Q: I think a lot of this can be simply answered by asking ourselves the following question: If your wife/sister/daughter …

ASA retreat

Dear David et al Sorry for my delay in responding. I’m visiting my girlfriend’s family in a rural part of Bulgaria wo …